“Which” and “That”: The Comma Tells You Which One
One introduces information you can remove; the other introduces information the sentence needs. The comma is not decoration — it changes the meaning.
Author
Nathan Cole writes the adjective guides and word lists on Grammar Simplified. Every guide he publishes is checked against Merriam-Webster for spelling and usage, the Chicago Manual of Style for punctuation, and the AP Stylebook where a convention is specific to web writing. Where a rule is genuinely disputed among those authorities, he says so in the guide rather than picking a side quietly. Corrections are welcome and get acted on — see the editorial policy.
900 guides published
One introduces information you can remove; the other introduces information the sentence needs. The comma is not decoration — it changes the meaning.
Affect is usually the verb, effect is usually the noun, and the exceptions are rare enough to learn individually.
Everyone knows sentences and names. The trouble is job titles, seasons, directions, and the compulsion to capitalise anything that feels important.
It marks something left out, or it marks a sentence trailing away. It does not mean “and so on”, and it is not a general-purpose pause.
It works by being rare. Use two on a page and neither means anything, which is why professional writing has quietly abandoned it.
Joining two sentences with a comma is the most common punctuation error in English. It is also a deliberate device, and telling the two apart is the whole skill.
The same aside can be whispered, spoken or announced. Three pairs of marks, three volumes, and most writers only ever use one.
One job, one test. If the words before it do not form a complete sentence, the colon is in the wrong place.
American and British English disagree, and the American rule was invented for the convenience of typesetters rather than for logic.
Nobody struggles with the dog’s bone. The trouble is plurals, names ending in s, and the one case where the apostrophe should not be there at all.
Grammar Simplified
Plain-English grammar guides and curated adjective lists. Free to read, checked against Merriam-Webster, Chicago and AP before publication.
194 grammar guides →