Adjective Clauses: Relative Clauses That Describe a Noun
An adjective clause (also called a relative clause) is a group of words with its own subject and verb that describes a noun. It usually starts with who, whom, whose, which or that, or with where, when or why, and comes right after the noun it describes: The engineer who fixed the boiler left early. The clause tells you which engineer, and it has its own subject (who) and verb (fixed).
Clause or phrase?
The subject and verb are the whole difference. The engineer eager to leave contains an adjective phrase: no subject, no finite verb. The engineer who was eager to leave contains an adjective clause. Both describe the noun; only the clause could stand as a sentence if you replaced the pronoun (“He was eager to leave”). More on the shorter form in adjective phrases.
The words that start an adjective clause
| Word | Used for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people, as the subject of the clause | the woman who called |
| whom | people, as the object (formal) | the woman whom we called |
| whose | possession, for people or things | the car whose alarm failed |
| which | things and animals | the report, which arrived late |
| that | people or things, in defining clauses only | the report that arrived late |
| where | places | the café where we met |
| when | times | the year when it snowed in May |
| why | reasons, after “the reason” | the reason why she left |
Who or whom? Whom is fading in speech but survives in formal writing. If you are unsure, turn the clause into a plain sentence and test it with he or him: we called him, so whom; he called, so who.
Where, or which … in? Both work: the house where I grew up = the house in which I grew up = the house (that) I grew up in.
The commas change the meaning
This is the part worth getting right, because the punctuation is not decoration: it decides what the sentence claims.
- Defining (no commas): The staff who trained in March passed. Only some staff trained in March, and only those passed.
- Non-defining (commas): The staff, who trained in March, passed. All the staff trained in March, and all of them passed.
A defining clause picks out which one. A non-defining clause adds extra information about something already identified, so you could delete it and the sentence would still point to the same thing. Two commas turn a filter into an aside. In a contract or a report that difference matters, which is why editors treat it as more than a style point.
| Defining | Non-defining | |
|---|---|---|
| Commas | none | before and after (or before a full stop) |
| Job | identifies which one | adds extra information |
| “That” allowed? | yes | no; use who or which |
| Pronoun can be dropped? | yes, if it is the object | never |
| Example | The phone that I bought last week has broken. | My phone, which I bought last week, has broken. |
A quick test: with a proper name or a unique thing (my mother, Paris, the sun), the clause is almost always non-defining, because the noun is already identified: My mother, who lives in Leeds, is visiting. Writing it without commas implies you have more than one mother.
When you can drop the pronoun
If the relative pronoun is the object of its clause, English lets you leave it out in a defining clause: the book that I ordered and the book I ordered are both correct. If it is the subject, it has to stay: the book that arrived cannot become the book arrived, which says something else entirely.
- The film (that) we watched was too long. (object: can drop)
- The film that won the prize was too long. (subject: must keep)
- The colleague (whom) I mentioned has left. (object: can drop)
Prepositions in adjective clauses
When the clause needs a preposition, you can put it at the end (everyday) or before whom/which (formal):
- the person I spoke to / the person to whom I spoke
- the project we worked on / the project on which we worked
After a preposition, use whom and which, never who or that: not “the person to who I spoke”, not “the project on that we worked”.
When to cut the clause instead
Adjective clauses are often longer than the job requires. Removing the pronoun and a form of be usually leaves a tighter phrase that means the same thing.
- the candidates who were eager to begin → the candidates eager to begin
- the report which was written in June → the report written in June
- the man who is standing by the door → the man standing by the door
Do this once or twice in a paragraph and the prose tightens noticeably. What is left is an adjective phrase doing the same work in fewer words.
More examples
- Students who submit late lose ten per cent. (defining: only those students)
- Our head teacher, who has worked here for twenty years, is retiring. (non-defining)
- That is the shop where I bought my bike.
- I still remember the day when we moved house.
- The author whose novel won the prize is only twenty-four.
- He finally replied to the email, which surprised everyone. (here which refers to the whole idea of his replying)
Common mistakes
- “That” after a comma: “My car, that is ten years old, still runs” → “My car, which is ten years old, still runs.”
- Only one comma: “My sister, who lives in Spain is a nurse” → “My sister, who lives in Spain, is a nurse.” A non-defining clause in mid-sentence needs a comma at both ends.
- “Which” for people: “the doctor which treated me” → “the doctor who (or that) treated me”.
- An extra pronoun: “the book that I bought it” → “the book that I bought”. The relative pronoun already stands for the object.
- Clause far from its noun: “I met a man at the station who sold hats” can sound as though the station sold hats. Better: “At the station I met a man who sold hats.”
- Using “what” as a relative: “the film what we saw” is non-standard; use “that” or nothing.
For relative clauses in more depth, including reduced and sentential clauses, see relative clauses.
Practice
Choose the pronoun and decide whether commas are needed.
- The tenants ___ paid on time were not affected. (only some tenants paid on time)
- My brother ___ lives in Leeds is visiting. (I have one brother)
- The laptop ___ screen cracked is still under warranty.
- The report ___ I submitted on Friday has been approved.
- She thanked the driver ___ had waited for her.
- This is the village ___ my grandparents were born.
- Correct the error: “The museum, that opened in 1990, is free.”
- Shorten the clause: “The woman who is sitting by the window is my aunt.”
Answers
| # | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | who / that, no commas | it identifies which tenants |
| 2 | My brother, who lives in Leeds, is visiting. | one brother, so the clause is extra information |
| 3 | whose | possession; whose works for things too |
| 4 | that / which, or nothing | the pronoun is the object, so it can be dropped |
| 5 | who (or that) | subject of its own clause, so it cannot be dropped |
| 6 | where (or “in which”) | a place |
| 7 | The museum, which opened in 1990, is free. | no “that” after a comma |
| 8 | The woman sitting by the window is my aunt. | drop “who is” |
Checked against Merriam-Webster, the Chicago Manual of Style and the AP Stylebook. Spotted an error? Tell us — see our editorial policy.
